06 Dec 2019 14:47:33
So who on here thinks Silva and Carvalho will start tonight?
And who on here thinks they SHOULD both start.


1.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 15:15:35
No and no
Carvalhio even if a super sub needs to be a match winner more often and the odd 20 minutes every now and then when he play well isn't good enough whether he cost 13 million or 13 pence we can't be carrying him anymore. Silva is a decent player needs more goals and assists though, he will start but him and Carvalhio too similar and it doesn't work. Silva can improve and needs to but has shown more this season than Carvalhio has in all his time here. don't want to keep knocking the bloke but I bet there isn't too many teams in our league that would show an interest in signing him. Think the fans have been patient enough and sang his name long enough, if that doesn't inspire you to play better then simply your not good enough. Any offers in January from abroad take it move on. On another note only 1 win in 11 against the Lions with 4 draws and 6 defeats going to be a tough one and think a draw is the most we will manage. Another big physical team my mates a Brummie fan and told me there 2 centre halves are huge and just bullied his team last week something we haven't got to grips with yet.


2.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 15:18:03
I don't like to see them play together and now semedo has some minutes under his belt again I'd bring him in but then it would be a toss up between carvalho and Silva, what concerns me with silva is his final ball his shooting and his dead ball deliveries they are poor and he doesn't have a goal in him by the looks of it, runs and runs but we had one like that before, Osborn.


3.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 16:20:47
Silva is better than Osborn.


4.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 16:28:41
Fff79 if carvallho had played as well as silva did against derby you’d still be going on about it now, and if he plays them together tonight millwall will walk straight through us,


5.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 16:30:04
Not doing a comparison as to who is the better player just he has similar traits to Osborn.
He took 9 corners on Saturday plus free kicks that never troubled anyone and his free kicks have been terrible all season, having said that can't fault his industry.


6.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 16:59:15
Stevie I've said I don't like to see them play together but Silva is no world beater.


7.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 17:10:16
Silva is a good tackler Osborne rarely did, and Carvalho is not good at it.


8.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 17:34:06
Ff if silva was anything like a world beater A. he wouldn’t have cost next to jack s, and B
he wouldn’t be here mate.


9.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 17:48:14
No 10s aren't expected to be good tacklers they are expected to set up and score goals.


10.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 17:57:44
Well you are stating the obvious but 2.5 mill isn't Jack in the championship.


11.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 18:27:55
Ff 13.2 mill obviously is to some of you, lot of money for a bench warmer.


12.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 18:48:33
Stevie I get it you hate carvalho.
I didn't pay the money not did you it was what the owners wanted so get over it.


13.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 19:16:26
Ff I don’t hate anyone mate it’s football, I just get a little bored with being told how good the ‘Little genius ‘is when it’s blatantly obvious he’s pretty ordinary.


14.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 19:44:47
They are nearly all ordinary its championship football.


15.) 06 Dec 2019
06 Dec 2019 20:14:13
It was you that called him the little genius not me.